Ambulance Diversions Following Public Hospital Emergency Department Closures - PubMed

Ambulance Diversions Following Public Hospital Emergency Department Closures - PubMed

Ambulance Diversions Following Public Hospital Emergency Department Closures

Charleen Hsuan 1, Renee Y Hsia 2, Jill R Horwitz 3, Ninez A Ponce 4, Thomas Rice 4, Jack Needleman 4

Affiliations 

• PMID: 30941753
 
• PMCID: PMC6606538 (available on 2020-08-01)
 
• DOI: 10.1111/1475-6773.13147

Abstract

Objective: To examine whether hospitals are more likely to temporarily close their emergency departments (EDs) to ambulances (through ambulance diversions) if neighboring diverting hospitals are public vs private.

Data sources/study setting: Ambulance diversion logs for California hospitals, discharge data, and hospital characteristics data from California's Office of Statewide Health Planning and Development and the American Hospital Association (2007).

Study design: We match public and private (nonprofit or for-profit) hospitals by distance and size. We use random-effects models examining diversion probability and timing of private hospitals following diversions by neighboring public vs matched private hospitals.

Data collection/extraction methods: N/A.

Principal findings: Hospitals are 3.6 percent more likely to declare diversions if neighboring diverting hospitals are public vs private (P < 0.001). Hospitals declaring diversions have lower ED occupancy (P < 0.001) after neighboring public (vs private) hospitals divert. Hospitals have 4.2 percent shorter diversions if neighboring diverting hospitals are public vs private (P < 0.001). When the neighboring hospital ends its diversion first, hospitals terminate diversions 4.2 percent sooner if the neighboring hospital is public vs private (P = 0.022).

Conclusions: Sample hospitals respond differently to diversions by neighboring public (vs private) hospitals, suggesting that these hospitals might be strategically declaring ambulance diversions to avoid treating low-paying patients served by public hospitals.

Keywords: access to care; ambulance diversion; emergency department.

© Health Research and Educational Trust.

Similar articles

• Ambulance Diversion Associated With Reduced Access to Cardiac Technology and Increased One-Year Mortality

  YC Shen et al. Health Aff (Millwood) 34 (8), 1273-80. Aug 2015. PMID 26240239.

  Ambulance diversion, which occurs when a hospital emergency department (ED) is temporarily closed to incoming ambulance traffic, is an important system-level interruption …
• Is Inpatient Volume Or Emergency Department Crowding A Greater Driver Of Ambulance Diversion?

  RY Hsia et al. Health Aff (Millwood) 37 (7), 1115-1122. Jul 2018. PMID 29985688.

  Inpatient volume has long been believed to be a contributing factor to ambulance diversion, which can lead to delayed treatment and poorer outcomes. We examined the exten …
• Analysis of Ambulance Transports and Diversions Among US Emergency Departments

  CW Burt et al. Ann Emerg Med 47 (4), 317-26. Apr 2006. PMID 16546615.

  Description of current use of ED ambulance transports and likelihood of diversions should help policymakers plan for demographic changes in the population during the next …
• Ambulance Diversion and Emergency Department Offload Delay: Resource Document for the National Association of EMS Physicians Position Statement

  DR Cooney et al. Prehosp Emerg Care 15 (4), 555-61. Oct-Dec 2011. PMID 21870947. - Review

  The emergency medical services (EMS) system is a component of a larger health care safety net and a key component of an integrated emergency health care system. EMS syste …
• Overcrowding in the Nation's Emergency Departments: Complex Causes and Disturbing Effects

  RW Derlet et al. Ann Emerg Med 35 (1), 63-8. Jan 2000. PMID 10613941. - Review

  Ten years ago, serious overcrowding in emergency departments became a national issue. Although temporary improvement of the problem occurred, the issue of ED overcrowding …