Assisted dying activists sue to force UK doctors to change policy
by Michael Cook | 19 Sep 2020 |
British activists are threatening the Royal College of General Practitioners with legal action for continuing to oppose the legalisation of assisted dying.
Earlier in the year the RCGP surveyed its members about the highly contentious issue. Only about 13% of the RCGP’s 50,000 members responded. Of these, 47% said that the RCGP should oppose a change in the law on assisted dying; 40% supported a change; and 11% supported neutrality. (About 2% abstained.)
The RCGP’s Council agreed that the survey results did not support a change in the College's existing position on assisted dying. It also decided that it will not review its position for at least five years unless there were significant developments.
This position is “irrational”, according to its critics.
The trend is clear: support for opposition has fallen since 2013, the last time that members were consulted by the RCGP. And support for legalisation has risen sharply. Nonetheless, a plurality still favoured maintenance of the status quo.
Opponents have seized on the fact that the status quo did not have majority support.
“The College is failing in its obligations to properly represent the views of its members,” say RCGP members Aneez Esmail and Sam Everington, the Good Law Project, and the pressure group Dignity in Dying.
In a solicitor’s letter they accuse the college of “a flawed and unlawful decision-making process” that was “irrational, failed to take into account relevant factors and took into account irrelevant factors.”
The letter says: “With such a polarised result on an important ethical issue there was a fundamental error in treating ‘neutrality’ as a stand-alone third option as opposed to representing the middle ground between two competing, but polar opposite, views with similar levels of support.
“The results in this case clearly supported change in the College’s position and so neutrality is arguably the only logical way of reflecting that change.”
With neither two side having a clear majority in some of the professional colleges, dissident doctors seem to be resorting to the courts. Last year, when the Royal College of Physicians adopted a position of “neutrality” even though a plurality opposed it, four doctors attempted to contest the administrators’ decision. However, the High Court refused to hear the case.
Michael Cook is editor of BioEdge
Judge Amy Coney Barrett gave a gracious acceptance speech after being nominated by President Trump to the US Supreme Court. “The flag of the United States is still flying at half staff in memory of Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg to mark the end of a great American life,” she said. “She not only broke glass ceilings, but she smashed them. She was a woman of enormous talent and consequences and her life of public service serves as an example to us all.”
It was a moving tribute to RBG, but ACB is expected to help shift SCOTUS in a very different direction – more conservative, and above all, more sceptical of abortion. As I wrote before, bioethics is “at the very centre of this strange election”.
Michael Cook
Editor
It was a moving tribute to RBG, but ACB is expected to help shift SCOTUS in a very different direction – more conservative, and above all, more sceptical of abortion. As I wrote before, bioethics is “at the very centre of this strange election”.
Michael Cook
Editor
NEWS THIS WEEK
by Michael Cook | Sep 27, 2020
But don’t expect a quick reversal of Roe v Wade even if she is confirmedby Michael Cook | Sep 27, 2020
Who are the modern equivalents of Genghis Khan?by Michael Cook | Sep 27, 2020
The fertility rate will drop to an all-time low of 1.59 during this financial yearby Michael Cook | Sep 27, 2020
‘Bioethics has pushed too far in the direction of the individual,’ says scholarby Michael Cook | Sep 27, 2020
But is there really ‘no evidence’ that they are dangerous?by Michael Cook | Sep 27, 2020
We cannot leave vulnerable patients behindby Michael Cook | Sep 27, 2020
New document clarifies some points for uneasy Catholics BioEdge
L1, Unit 7, 11 Lord Street · Botany, NSW 2019 · Australia
Phone: +61 2 8005 8605
Mobile: 0422-691-615
.png)
No hay comentarios:
Publicar un comentario