US health official reminds states that triage cannot trump civil rights
by Michael Cook | 5 Apr 2020 |
The civil rights office of the US Department of Health and Human Services has issued a stern bulletin warning that doctors must not discriminate on the basis of disability, race, age or other factors if triage becomes necessary during the coronavirus pandemic.
“HHS is committed to leaving no one behind during an emergency,” said Roger Severino. “Persons with disabilities, with limited English skills, or needing religious accommodations should not be put at the end of the line for health services during emergencies. Our civil rights laws protect the equal dignity of every human life from ruthless utilitarianism.”
As the states struggle to cope with growing numbers in hospitals, disability groups have expressed their concerns that the disabled might be denied treatment. According to the New York Times,
Some [state] plans instruct hospitals not to offer mechanical ventilators to people above a certain age or with particular health conditions.
In Alabama’s plan, people with “severe or profound mental retardation” as well as “moderate to severe dementia” should be considered “unlikely candidates for ventilator support” during a period of rationing. Washington’s guidance recommends that triage teams consider transferring hospital patients with “loss of reserves in energy, physical ability, cognition and general health” to outpatient or palliative care.
But the Office for Civil Rights (OCR) suggests that such plans could be challenged.
In this time of emergency, the laudable goal of providing care quickly and efficiently must be guided by the fundamental principles of fairness, equality, and compassion that animate our civil rights laws. This is particularly true with respect to the treatment of persons with disabilities during medical emergencies as they possess the same dignity and worth as everyone else.
... persons with disabilities should not be denied medical care on the basis of stereotypes, assessments of quality of life, or judgments about a person’s relative “worth” based on the presence or absence of disabilities or age. Decisions by covered entities concerning whether an individual is a candidate for treatment should be based on an individualized assessment of the patient based on the best available objective medical evidence.
The NYTimes points out that strict application of criteria could kill people who could otherwise survive. For instance, triage plans often state that people should be removed from ventilators if they do not appear to be improving. But:
In some states, including New York, people who required ventilators long-term, such as those who have certain spinal cord injuries, could be subject to having their ventilators reassigned under the protocol if they were admitted to hospitals during the crisis.
If triage has to be applied, Mr Severino said, it must comply with civil rights laws. “Ultimately the question as to resource allocation is not a scientific or medical one,” he told the NYTimes. “It is ultimately a moral and legal one.”
Michael Cook is editor of BioEdge
One of the saddest stories from the coronavirus pandemic comes from Iran. As of Friday, there had been 53,000 cases and 3,300 deaths. But, adding to the country's misery, hundreds of people have died after drinking methanol as a “remedy”. It illustrates the danger of a panicked response to the virus. Most of our other stories revolve around the crisis as well.
We'll be taking a break next week for the Easter holiday. See you later in the month.
Michael Cook
Editor, BioEdge
We'll be taking a break next week for the Easter holiday. See you later in the month.
Michael Cook
Editor, BioEdge
NEWS THIS WEEK
by Michael Cook | Apr 05, 2020
‘Our civil rights laws protect the equal dignity of every human life from ruthless utilitarianism’by Michael Cook | Apr 05, 2020
Bootleg methanol kills and blindsby Michael Cook | Apr 05, 2020
Bill passes almost unnoticed in pandemic panicby Michael Cook | Apr 05, 2020
‘The Lancet’ warns that draconian measures can harm the poorby | Apr 05, 2020
WHO has neglected the negative externalities of social distancingby Michael Cook | Apr 05, 2020
While the public is distractedby Michael Cook | Apr 05, 2020
The media shouldn’t extrapolate from a few remarksby Xavier Symons | Apr 05, 2020
Ethics is proving increasingly relevant to the coronavirus crisis.by Xavier Symons | Apr 04, 2020
Commentators say wet-markets are unethical and a danger to humanity. BioEdge
Level 1, 488 Botany Road, Alexandria NSW 2015 Australia
Phone: +61 2 8005 8605
Mobile: 0422-691-615
No hay comentarios:
Publicar un comentario