GESTIÓN EN SALUD PÚBLICA: New South Wales debates the decriminalisation of abortion

domingo, 4 de agosto de 2019

New South Wales debates the decriminalisation of abortion

New South Wales debates the decriminalisation of abortion

Bioedge

New South Wales debates decriminalisation of abortion

by Xavier Symons | 3 Aug 2019 | 2 comments

Politicians in the New South Wales State Parliament are about to commence debate on a controversial bill that would decriminalise abortion and provide a legislative framework for terminations throughout pregnancy.

The Reproductive Health Care Reform Bill 2019 has been described by supporters as an “update” to an “archaic” section of the state's Crimes Act. Section 82 of this 119-year-old Act states that abortion is a criminal offence liable to 10 years imprisonment. The bill would remove this section from the Crimes Act and would allow women to access abortion for any reason up to 22 weeks gestation. Beyond this, abortion would be legal for women who have obtained approval from two doctors.

The bill also includes a mandatory referral clause, whereby doctors with a conscientious objection to abortion must refer patients seeking an abortion to a doctor or service willing to provide the procedure.

“Now is the time for the parliament to come together to ensure women and their doctors are appropriately protected under the law,” Alex Greenwich, the principal sponsor of the bill, told MPs on Thursday.

It is understood that the legislation has broad support in both the lower and upper houses. The bill was co-sponsored by 15 MPs, and has the support of both the Premier and leader of the opposition Labor Party.

Yet there has also been strong opposition to the bill from both parliamentarians and pro-life lobby groups. State Minister for Finance Damien Tudehope described the bill as “unjust and illiberal” and warned colleagues that the “community won’t stand for it”. Liberal MP Nathaniel Smith said that the bill “will not protect women”.

There are also concerns that the bill sanctions sex-selective abortion and abortion on the grounds of disability.

The Legislative Assembly will not adjourn this week until it has voted on the bill.

Xavier Symons is deputy editor of BioEdge

The ever-volatile issue of stem cell research is back on the boil. Earlier this week a Japanese researcher announced that he would be creating human-mouse chimeras -- and bringing them to term. This is controversial stuff, but at least the researcher waited until he had obtained a thumbs-up from Japanese authorities.

Not to be outdone, a Spanish researcher announced soon afterwards this week that she and her colleagues in Spain and the United States are going to create human-monkey chimeras.

Monkeys? Isn't this even more controversial? Yes, of course it is, she told the media. But it's OK: we're doing it in China where ethical standards are lower.

How do you classify that sort of attitude toward ethics? Arrogant? Undemocratic? Secretive? Publicity-hungry? Immoral? Take your pick.