A doctor who stayed
by Michael Cook | 8 Sep 2018 |
Hospital in Idlib destroyed in 2016 / Médecins Sans Frontières
Healthcare workers, clinics and hospitals have been consistently targeted by the Assad government during Syria’s bitter civil war. Many doctors have fled. In this video the New York Times interviews one doctor, Mohammed al-Bardan, who has decided to stay to care for his people.
According to the World Health Organisation, “8 years into the conflict in the Syrian Arab Republic, attacks on health care facilities and personnel in the country continue to rise despite United Nations resolutions strongly condemning these attacks. In the first 6 months of 2018, there were 126 separate attacks on health care in Syria – more than for the whole of 2017. Syria now accounts for a staggering 70% of all attacks on health care facilities documented by WHO worldwide.”
Sunday, September 9, 2018
John Robertson was an American scholar in law and bioethics who died last year. He is best known for making a strong case for “procreative liberty”, whether procreation takes place naturally or with the help of technology. As a tribute to his influence, the current issue of the Journal of Law and the Biosciences contains several articles about this theory.
Robertson’s theme was that reproductive choices which do not harm the interests of others should not be subject to regulation or prohibition. In his best-known book, Children of Choice, published in 1996, he discussed abortion, IVF, surrogacy and pre-natal genetic modification. But time has moved on. The principle of effectively unconstrained “procreative liberty” is being used to justify other developments, some of which are discussed in the Journal, including unisex gestation.
What I found interesting was that Robertson, in a paper written not long before his death, agreed that a male pregnancy (after a womb transplant) could be ethically justified, but only if it were necessary for genetic reproduction. Even he wanted to draw a line somewhere.
However, the author of one of tribute essays questions this restriction. Enjoying the experience of gestation is reason enough, she says. (See below). I suppose that this raises the question of whether it is possible to draw any lines, anywhere, once we agree that reproductive rights should not be limited.
Robertson’s theme was that reproductive choices which do not harm the interests of others should not be subject to regulation or prohibition. In his best-known book, Children of Choice, published in 1996, he discussed abortion, IVF, surrogacy and pre-natal genetic modification. But time has moved on. The principle of effectively unconstrained “procreative liberty” is being used to justify other developments, some of which are discussed in the Journal, including unisex gestation.
What I found interesting was that Robertson, in a paper written not long before his death, agreed that a male pregnancy (after a womb transplant) could be ethically justified, but only if it were necessary for genetic reproduction. Even he wanted to draw a line somewhere.
However, the author of one of tribute essays questions this restriction. Enjoying the experience of gestation is reason enough, she says. (See below). I suppose that this raises the question of whether it is possible to draw any lines, anywhere, once we agree that reproductive rights should not be limited.
 Michael Cook Editor BioEdge |  |  |  |
NEWS THIS WEEK
by Michael Cook | Sep 08, 2018
Supporters want to extend its funding by Michael Cook | Sep 08, 2018
With womb transplants on the way, we have to ask the question by Xavier Symons | Sep 08, 2018
A pregnant Jehovah's Witness teenager had refused the procedureby Xavier Symons | Sep 08, 2018
Diabetics are rationing insulin injections. by Xavier Symons | Sep 08, 2018
Doctors at the Moscow clinic cooperated with the woman's request. by Michael Cook | Sep 08, 2018
How does one choose amongst 10,000 options? by Michael Cook | Sep 08, 2018
Nearly 40 people have died in 2018 by Michael Cook | Sep 08, 2018
Larger studies are needed to confirm results by Michael Cook | Sep 08, 2018
Mohammed al-Bardan explains to the New York Times why he cares for patients in a rebel-held district of Syria BioEdge
Suite 12A, Level 2 | 5 George St | North Strathfield NSW 2137 | Australia
Phone: +61 2 8005 8605
Mobile: 0422-691-615
No hay comentarios:
Publicar un comentario