After more than 2,000 deaths, most of them civilians, I ought to write something about the war in Gaza. But it is excruciatingly difficult for no matter what you say, it will be denounced by one side or the other as biased and idiotic.
The Lancet recently published an incendiary letter attacking Israel which provoked furious replies from Israeli doctors. One allegation was that The Lancet had lowered its high editorial standards by publishing politically biased material.
I'm not sure whether this holds water. The Lancet - and most of the other leading journals, like Science, Nature, JAMA, the New England Journal of Medicine - often take sides on issues like abortion, euthanasia, healthcare and so on. They don't ignore them and hope that they will disappear. Why not a war?
Well, for one thing, wars are even more ethically snarled than abortion. It may be beyond the wit of the editors. Painting one side as the villain is simply wrong; both sides have made bad choices.
Nonetheless I think that it is important for medical journals at least to point out that war is always a deeply ethical issue, not just a utilitarian calculus. If doctors are supposed to be custodians of humane values, their journals ought to be ethical gadflies.
That's why I think that The Lancet is right to take a stand on this tragic war and the that the other journals have been remiss, perhaps even cowardly, in ignoring it. What do you think?
by Michael Cook | Aug 23, 2014The numbers of 'suicide tourists' going to Switzerland to take their own lives has doubled in four years, reports a study published online in the...
by Michael Cook | Aug 23, 2014How to deal with the Ebola outbreak in West Africa seems to be splitting bioethicists.
by Michael Cook | Aug 23, 2014The war between Hamas in Gaza and Israel has been treated very gingerly by most of the major medical journals. Except The Lancet.
by Xavier Symons | Aug 23, 2014A number of healthcare commentators are calling for 'compensation' for donors.
by Xavier Symons | Aug 23, 2014An revealing new study published in the Journal of Medical Ethics examines the attitudes of medical students towards conscientious objection.
by Xavier Symons | Aug 23, 2014A British cosmetic surgeon has been struck off the register for putting commercial interests before patient care.
by Michael Cook | Aug 22, 2014Iran is to ban vasectomies and female sterilization in an effort to reverse its plummeting birth rate
by Michael Cook | Aug 22, 2014Dawkins is in hot water again after asserting on Twitter that it is "immoral" to allow Down Syndrome babies to be born.
by Michael Cook | Aug 22, 2014A fascinating article in the Journal of Medicine and Philosophy argues that rich white men are also vulnerable to euthanasia.
Suite 12A, Level 2 | 5 George St | North Strathfield NSW 2137 | Australia
Phone: +61 2 8005 8605
No hay comentarios:
Publicar un comentario