I am really working above my paygrade here, but I propose a thorough revision of Lewis Henry Morgan’s classic text, Systems of Consanguinity and Affinity of the Human Family. Back in 1871 he identified six fundamental systems that languages have for classifying relatives: Hawaiian, Sudanese, Eskimo, Iroquois, Crow and Omaha. (English is regarded as an Eskimo-type language.)
Of these six systems, the most complex is the one used in southern Sudan. Every possible relationship has a unique word to describe it, whether it is “mother” or “mother’s brother’s first son’s youngest daughter”.
In the course of probing research into kinship terms over the past 20 minutes I discovered that nowadays Morgan’s classifications are considered outdated. At least one more system has been discovered, the Dravidian system, and some languages add refinements like distinguishing between older brother and younger brother. Some Australian Aboriginal languages use the same terms of address for alternating generations.
If you have got this far, you are probably getting a bit impatient.
My point is that we need a new burst of creativity to invent new words for relationships created by assisted reproductive technology. In this week’s newsletter, for instance, we have a biological mother acting as surrogate mother for her biological son. A couple of weeks ago, we reported a lesbian using her brother’s sperm to impregnate her partner. English is already poor in kinship terms. Can it possibly cope with the pressure of surrogacy and gamete donation or even gamete creation?
We have reason to hope.
The roots of modern English are in Anglo-Saxon and (remotely) Latin. Both of these defunct languages followed the Sudanese system, with different names for each relationship. Anglo-Saxon, for instance, had eight different terms for cousin. What they did, we can do. Any suggestions?
|This week in BioEdge|
by Xavier Symons | Mar 07, 2015The majority of Canada’s palliative care specialists don’t want to participate in assisted suicide, according to a new survey.
by Xavier Symons | Mar 07, 2015Indonesia has come under intense scrutiny for its decision to execute two Australian nationals convicted of drug smuggling.
by Michael Cook | Mar 07, 2015This week’s story from Britain wins the New Frontiers Award in Assisted Reproductive Technology hands down.
by Michael Cook | Mar 07, 2015The Irish Fertility Society has called upon the Oireachtas to scupper new assisted reproduction regulations.
by Michael Cook | Mar 07, 2015More than 1.5% of the babies born in the United States in 2013 began life in a Petri dish.
by Michael Cook | Mar 07, 2015“Doing the Most Good” is an apology for “effective altruism”.
by Michael Cook | Mar 07, 2015Health care workers face agonising dilemmas.
by Michael Cook | Mar 07, 2015The last known Ebola patient in Liberia has been discharged from a Chinese-run clinic.
by Michael Cook | Mar 07, 2015Was he the world's most famous spokesman for the creed of Jeremy Bentham?
Suite 12A, Level 2 | 5 George St | North Strathfield NSW 2137 | Australia
Phone: +61 2 8005 8605
No hay comentarios:
Publicar un comentario