Hi there,
After a month of false leads and dashed hopes, it is time to question whether the search for the lost Malaysian Airlines flight 370 is worthwhile. This is the question posed by Glenn Cohen, a professor at Harvard Law School, recently.
Cohen is being deliberately provocative, but since the cost of the search will probably be hundreds of millions of dollars, it’s a utilitarian question worth pondering. He points out that US$100 million (a very conservative estimate of the cost) could save 52,192 life years if the same amount were spent on vaccinating children.
No governments have asked this question; they are blindly determined to find the plane and learn the fate of the 239 people on board. Cohen lists a few of the reasons why: to learn what went wrong to prevent future incidents, to bring closure for relatives, and to satisfy the voyeuristic instincts of media consumers.
To these should be added: ingratiating themselves with China (most of the passengers were Chinese) and promoting regional cooperation in a dangerous area of the world.
Cohen says that this may just be an example of our bias toward identifiable lives over “statistical lives”, a point often made by Peter Singer. There is certainly more than a germ of truth in this, but something tells me that there is more to it.
Ultimately, the only excuse for the existence of governments is defending the common good. A government which is indifferent to the welfare and emotional needs of its citizens will not last. Disaster victims have been treated so abominably in the recent past in China that the new President, Xi Jinping, is probably desperate to portray himself as a defender of his restless citizens’ rights. His government’s stability may depend on it. That may be the strongest reason for continuing the search.
Any thoughts?
Michael Cook
Editor
Office address: 75 Archer Street | Chatswood NSW 2067 | Australia
Phone: 61+2 9007-1187
Mobile: 0422-691-615
Email: michael@bioedge.org
|
Michael Cook
Editor
BioEdge
Editor
BioEdge
| This week in BioEdge | |
by Michael Cook | Apr 06, 2014
Once again, a promising method comes unstuck after allegations of scientific misconduct.
by Michael Cook | Apr 05, 2014
How could a 30-year-old junior researcher at a leading institute report incredible results in the world's leading science journal despite dubious data?
by Michael Cook | Apr 05, 2014
Here is a quick and helpful video overview of concerns with the peer review process.
by Michael Cook | Apr 05, 2014
The Australian High Court has ruled that people can be officially recognised as a non-specific sex.
by Xavier Symons | Apr 04, 2014
Mexican authorities have accused the Knights Templar crime syndicate of kidnapping children to harvest their organs.
by Xavier Symons | Apr 04, 2014
A new healthcare analytics report has revealed just how big the IVF market is, and how big it is set to become.
by Xavier Symons | Apr 04, 2014
A recent article on stigmatization in reproductive health provides an unfortunately confused treatment of a topic of great contemporary relevance.
by Xavier Symons | Apr 04, 2014
Transhumanism has reached hollywood in a new high budget film called Transcendence.
.png)
No hay comentarios:
Publicar un comentario