One of the most famous obiter dicta from the US Supreme Court is Justice Anthony Kennedy’s “mystery” passage in the 1992 case Planned Parenthood v. Casey. “At the heart of liberty is the right to define one's own concept of existence, of meaning, of the universe, and of the mystery of human life.”
I’m sure that you will often hear it cited in the years ahead. It expresses perfectly the notion of freedom which underlies same-sex marriage and transgenderism, both of which will be on the boil for some time to come.
Kennedy’s eloquent words do sound appealing, but following them can lead us into an Alice in Wonderland world. For instance, Giuliana Mazzoni, a professor of psychology at the University of Hull in the UK, has suggested that artificial recreation of happy memories may become the next big weapon against depression. Depression blocks access to happy memories, but it might be possible for depressed people to artificially recreate good memories to allow for positive thinking.
If this technology becomes available – a big if – it could have very profitable commercial applications. Elderly people whose lives have been unhappy could get a loving spouse and a successful career for a few bucks. A drug addict could remember a steady job and an unbroken marriage. Bad memories could be erased.
According to Justice Kennedy’s understanding of liberty this would be completely ethical. If freedom is the opportunity to reshape reality, artificial memories would be a good thing. But somehow this defies common sense. A freedom that allows us to escape into a fantasy world rather than confronting reality is a peculiar freedom.
This week in BioEdge
by Michael Cook | Jun 20, 2015Protests by disability activists unnerved organisers
by Michael Cook | Jun 20, 2015Latest document causes media storm
by Xavier Symons | Jun 20, 2015US policy analysts are questioning how authorities should deal with the hundreds of thousands that have been abandoned or have a disputed legal status.
by Xavier Symons | Jun 20, 2015Japanese researchers have discovered a way to influence the sexual fate of germ cells in medaka (rice fish).
by Xavier Symons | Jun 20, 2015The devastating earthquake in Nepal last April unearthed the ongoing exploitation of young Indian migrants by surrogacy agents in Kathmandu.
by Xavier Symons | Jun 20, 2015The US media has been in a frenzy over allegations that civil rights activist Rachel Dolezal is really ‘white’.
by Michael Cook | Jun 20, 2015A country where more and more people are asking to be killed.
by Michael Cook | Jun 20, 2015Couples are far from indifferent about genetic links.
Suite 12A, Level 2 | 5 George St | North Strathfield NSW 2137 | Australia
Phone: +61 2 8005 8605
No hay comentarios:
Publicar un comentario