Canadian reproductive rights pioneer in disgrace over IVF mix-up
by Michael Cook | 5 Nov 2016 | 3 comments
Dr Norman Barwin after a disciplinary hearing in 2013
An Ottawa fertility specialist secretly used his own sperm to impregnate clients in the late 1980s, a lawsuit alleges. Two families claim that Dr Norman Barwin, who used to run the Broadview Fertility Clinic, negligently inseminated his patients with the wrong sperm, and it may have been his own. Since a law firm announced that it was commencing a class action, dozens of other couples have contacted it about their children.Dr Barwin is not an obscure rural physician. He is a past president of the Canadian Fertility Society, a past president of the Planned Parenthood Federation of Canada and the founder of Canadians for Choice. He was given the Order of Canada in 1997 for making “profound impact on both the biological and psycho-social aspects of women’s reproductive health.” He was a strong advocate for sex education, abortion rights and IVF for lesbians and single women.
His reputation took a nose dive in 2013 after he admitted that he mixed up the sperm of other clients. His registration to practice medicine was suspended for two months and he resigned from the Order of Canada.
However, Dr Barwin has never admitted that he used his own sperm to help his patients have children. The father of one of the families initiating the class action, Dan Dixon, told freelance documentary maker Alison Motluk that he had spent years swatting away comments that his daughter did not look like him. Only when his daughter Rebecca was in her 20s did they discover that she was not his biological daughter. Mr Dixon and his wife Davina are very angry.
"It's everyone's worst nightmare to hear that something like this could happen," said Mark Evans, executive director of the Canadian Fertility and Andrology Society, which represents about 150 clinics. However, he insisted that the Barwin case was exceptional. "This is an anomaly. It's not something that happens," he told CBC.
With the bicentenary of the publication of Mary Bysshe Shelley’s book on human enhancement approaching in 2018, it may be worth reviewing the dramatic bioethical challenge faced by Dr Frankenstein.
You may recall that Dr Victor Frankenstein assembled an eight-foot, highly intelligent, powerful male humanoid. His creation escaped but returned to plead for a female companion. With her he would emigrate to “the vast wilds of South America”. However, the good doctor fears that their progeny would compete with humankind. “A race of devils would be propagated upon earth who might make the very existence of the species of man a condition precarious and full of terror.”
So he destroys his female project. Did he make the right decision? Would these creatures really have destroyed the human race?
An article in the journal BioScience has crunched the numbers for us using “competitive exclusion” theory. It turns out that had the couple escaped to South America, they would have multiplied and spread, and eliminated us within 4000 years – 4,188 years to be exact. So, at least within a framework of utilitarian ethics, Frankenstein was right. He deserves the gratitude of BioEdge readers
Michael Cook
Editor
BioEdge
This week in BioEdge | |
by Michael Cook | Nov 05, 2016
Gaétan Dugas helped investigators but did not bring the disease to the USby Xavier Symons | Nov 05, 2016
Cambodia has become the latest South East Asian nation to ban commercial surrogacy.by Michael Cook | Nov 05, 2016
Even the province's health minister is surprisedby Michael Cook | Nov 05, 2016
A British academic questions the progressiveness of genetic engineeringby Michael Cook | Nov 05, 2016
Dr Norman Barwin is being sued by former clientsby Xavier Symons | Nov 05, 2016
Abortion by prescription now rivals surgery in the US, according to 2014 Planned Parenthood data.by Xavier Symons | Nov 05, 2016
Washington DC City Council voted to legalise euthanasia on Tuesday.by Michael Cook | Nov 05, 2016
Leading editor responds to his criticsby Michael Cook | Nov 05, 2016
Zoltan Istvan's policies sound odd, but at least he lays his cards on the tableBioEdge
Suite 12A, Level 2 | 5 George St | North Strathfield NSW 2137 | Australia
Phone: +61 2 8005 8605
Mobile: 0422-691-615
Email: michael@bioedge.org
New Media Foundation | Level 2, 5 George St | North Strathfield NSW 2137 | AUSTRALIA | +61 2 8005 8605
No hay comentarios:
Publicar un comentario